Accommodation trading is a controversial practice in which two traders enter into a prearranged, non-competitive transaction that ignores the true market price of a security. The goal is often to artificially generate losses that can be used to reduce taxable income.
Although it may appear to offer short-term tax advantages, accommodation trading carries serious legal and financial risks, including potential penalties for tax fraud. Understanding how this practice works — and why it’s scrutinized by regulators — is crucial for investors aiming to remain compliant with tax and trading laws.
Definition: Accommodation trading involves coordinated buy and sell orders between two traders at a prearranged price, typically below market value.
Purpose: The main intent is to create artificial tax losses to offset capital gains and lower taxable income.
Mechanics: One trader intentionally incurs a loss, while the other gains, without reflecting actual market conditions.
Legal Risk: The IRS treats non–arm’s-length transactions and trades done solely for tax purposes as tax evasion or fraud.
Regulatory Oversight: Under IRS Revenue Ruling 97-53, losses from such trades are disallowed if the transaction is not genuine or lacks economic substance.
Tickeron's Offerings
The fundamental premise of technical analysis lies in identifying recurring price patterns and trends, which can then be used to forecast the course of upcoming market trends. Our journey commenced with the development of AI-based Engines, such as the Pattern Search Engine, Real-Time Patterns, and the Trend Prediction Engine, which empower us to conduct a comprehensive analysis of market trends. We have delved into nearly all established methodologies, including price patterns, trend indicators, oscillators, and many more, by leveraging neural networks and deep historical backtests. As a consequence, we've been able to accumulate a suite of trading algorithms that collaboratively allow our AI Robots to effectively pinpoint pivotal moments of shifts in market trends.
Unlike manipulative practices such as accommodation trading, Tickeron’s AI-driven trading tools promote transparency, accountability, and regulatory compliance in modern markets.
Tickeron’s suite of intelligent systems — including the Pattern Search Engine, Real-Time Pattern Detection, and Trend Prediction Engine — uses machine learning and deep historical analysis to identify authentic, data-driven trading opportunities. These tools analyze price action, volume patterns, and market sentiment to detect genuine inefficiencies rather than fabricate transactions.
By relying on AI-powered analytics, traders can avoid unethical or non-compliant strategies while improving performance based on legitimate signals. Tickeron’s algorithms are designed to reflect real market behavior, ensuring that all trading activity aligns with both regulatory standards and investor ethics.
In an accommodation trading arrangement, two traders agree to buy and sell the same security at the same predetermined price, often disconnected from the market’s actual value. Typically, one party takes a deliberate paper loss, while the other reports a corresponding gain.
For instance, suppose an investor purchased a stock for $50, and it currently trades at $40. Selling it on the open market would yield a legitimate $10 loss. However, by selling it to another trader for $30, the investor can record an artificial $20 loss — inflating the deductible amount used to offset gains elsewhere in their portfolio.
While this may temporarily reduce tax obligations, such actions are deceptive if the transaction lacks economic substance or fair market value justification.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has long regarded accommodation trading as a potential abuse of tax law. If a trade is not conducted at arm’s length — meaning both parties act independently and in their own economic interest — the IRS can disallow the losses and impose penalties.
According to IRS Revenue Ruling 97-53, any trade entered into solely for tax purposes may constitute tax fraud, carrying significant consequences such as fines, audits, and possible criminal liability. Even if not prosecuted as fraud, these trades can result in disallowed losses, nullifying their intended benefits.
Despite the risks, some investors continue to use accommodation trading to inflate losses and reduce taxable income. Common motivations include:
Offsetting capital gains from other investments.
Qualifying for certain tax credits or deductions.
Temporarily adjusting reported performance for portfolio rebalancing.
However, regulators have intensified scrutiny on such practices, and modern surveillance tools — including AI-driven transaction monitoring — make it increasingly difficult to conceal non-genuine trades.
Beyond legal implications, accommodation trading undermines market integrity by distorting the natural price discovery process. It also erodes trust among investors and regulators, leading to stricter enforcement and reputational damage for those involved.
Investors considering any tax-related trade should consult a qualified tax professional and ensure that all transactions reflect genuine economic activity. Transparency, proper documentation, and adherence to regulatory standards are essential for maintaining ethical trading practices.
Accommodation trading may appear to offer short-term tax benefits, but its long-term consequences — including IRS penalties and reputational harm — far outweigh the gains. The practice blurs the line between legitimate tax strategy and fraudulent manipulation, making it a high-risk approach for any investor.
Instead of engaging in questionable trading behavior, investors can leverage advanced tools like Tickeron’s AI-powered trading systems, which provide data-driven insights, ensure compliance, and help traders build sustainable success based on transparency and ethical practices.
What are Marketable Securities?