×
RSPD offers equal-weight exposure to roughly 48 large-cap consumer discretionary names in the S&P 500, spanning autos, hotels, e-commerce, restaurants, and apparel. XRT is an equal-weight, retail-only portfolio of about 75 holdings that reaches deep into mid- and small-cap retailers and carries meaningful consumer staples overlap.
Consumer bifurcation is the defining macro driver. The "K-shaped" economy is splitting spending between resilient higher-income shoppers and increasingly cost-conscious lower-income households, a dynamic that directly shapes XRT's broad retail exposure. Tariffs remain a live margin risk. Import levies are pressuring retailer costs and, in turn, consumer prices, keeping inflation sticky and complicating the Federal Reserve's path on interest rates.
Different scope, shared sector: IYC spans the entire consumer discretionary universe, while XRT is a pure-play on U.S. retail, making them related but not interchangeable exposures. Weighting contrast: IYC is market-cap weighted and dominated by mega-cap leaders, whereas XRT is modified equal-weighted, distributing risk across roughly 75 retail names.
FXD is a smart-beta (rules-based, factor-tilted) consumer discretionary fund that favors value and growth factors with a mid-cap bias, while IYC is a passive, market-cap-weighted fund dominated by mega-cap leaders. IYC is significantly cheaper (0.38% vs. 0.60% expense ratio) and far more liquid, with roughly four to five times the assets under management of FXD .
EBIZ is a narrow, global thematic fund focused on e-commerce enablement, while IYC is a broad, U.S.-centric consumer discretionary sector fund. IYC holds roughly 171 securities versus about 41 for EBIZ , giving it materially lower single-stock concentration and a more diversified large-cap profile.
IYC offers diversified exposure across the U.S. consumer discretionary economy with roughly 170 holdings, while ONLN is a concentrated, pure-play basket of about 22 online-retail names. Cost efficiency clearly favors IYC , which carries a 0.37% expense ratio versus 0.58% for ONLN .
IYC provides broad consumer discretionary exposure across roughly 166 holdings, while RTH is a concentrated, non-diversified retail portfolio of about 26 names. Both funds lean heavily on AMZN and WMT , but RTH carries a far larger single-stock bet on Amazon, with a roughly 20% weighting versus about 15% in IYC.
IYC is a market-cap-weighted consumer discretionary fund, while RSPD applies an equal-weight methodology, producing markedly different risk and concentration profiles. IYC holds roughly 160–170 stocks and is heavily concentrated in mega-caps such as AMZN and TSLA ; RSPD holds about 48–50 stocks with each position near 2–3%.
IYC is a broad, passively managed consumer discretionary ETF tracking the Russell 1000 Consumer Discretionary capped index, holding roughly 166–172 stocks with a 0.37% expense ratio. PEJ is a concentrated, smart-beta (rules-based factor) fund tracking the Dynamic Leisure & Entertainment Intellidex Index, holding roughly 30 stocks with a 0.57% expense ratio.
Both IYC and VCR are passively managed ETFs targeting U.S. consumer discretionary equities, but they track different indexes and diverge meaningfully in concentration and cost. VCR is dramatically cheaper, with a net expense ratio of roughly 0.09%, versus about 0.38% for IYC .
FDIS tracks the MSCI USA IMI Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, while IYC tracks the Russell 1000 Consumer Discretionary capped index — two different benchmarks with meaningfully different construction rules. Cost is a major differentiator: FDIS carries a 0.08% expense ratio, roughly one-fifth the cost of IYC at approximately 0.38%.
IYC tracks a Russell 1000 consumer discretionary index with roughly 160–175 holdings, while XLY tracks the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector Index with about 50 holdings, making IYC the more diversified of the two. XLY is significantly cheaper, with a net expense ratio of 0.08% versus IYC's 0.37%, a structural advantage that compounds over time.
IYC tracks the Russell 1000 Consumer Discretionary 40 Act 15/22.5 Daily Capped Index, offering passive exposure to U.S. consumer discretionary equities. The fund is highly concentrated in its largest names, with AMZN and TSLA together representing roughly 23% of total assets.
Rate-sensitive portfolio: With heavy exposure to housing, autos, and big-ticket goods, the fund's future outlook is closely tied to Federal Reserve interest-rate policy and borrowing costs. Concentrated mega-cap drivers: Amazon and Tesla alone represent roughly one-fifth of assets, meaning a handful of companies will disproportionately shape the ETF forecast.
Different exposure engines: FDIS is a market-cap-weighted consumer discretionary fund dominated by mega-caps, while XRT is an equal-weighted U.S. retail fund tilted toward small- and mid-cap names. Concentration vs. breadth: FDIS puts roughly 40% of assets in AMZN and TSLA , whereas XRT spreads weight near-evenly across about 75 retail stocks.
FDIS is a broad, low-cost, passive index fund covering the entire U.S. consumer discretionary sector, while IBUY is a niche, thematic fund focused specifically on companies generating significant revenue from online retail. Cost is a decisive structural difference: FDIS charges a 0.08% net expense ratio versus 0.65% for IBUY, a gap of roughly 57 basis points (a basis point equals 0.01%) that compounds meaningfully over time.
FDIS is a low-cost, passive, market-cap-weighted fund tracking the MSCI USA IMI Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, while FXD is a rules-based "smart beta" fund using the AlphaDEX multi-factor selection methodology. FDIS holds roughly 250 securities and is heavily concentrated in mega-cap leaders such as Amazon and Tesla, whereas FXD holds around 115–120 more evenly weighted, mid-cap-leaning names.
FDIS is a low-cost, U.S.-only consumer discretionary fund with a 0.08% expense ratio, while RXI adds global diversification at a higher 0.37%–0.41% cost. Both funds are concentrated in mega-cap names such as AMZN (Amazon) and TSLA (Tesla), but FDIS carries materially heavier weight in these two positions.
Different benchmarks, similar goal: FDIS tracks the MSCI USA IMI Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, while IYC tracks the Russell 1000 Consumer Discretionary 40 Act 15/22.5 Daily Capped Index. Cost gap is meaningful: FDIS charges 0.08%, versus 0.37% for IYC, giving FDIS a durable structural cost advantage.
FDIS is a market-capitalization-weighted fund tracking the MSCI USA IMI Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, while RSPD is an equal-weighted fund tracking the S&P 500 Equal Weight Consumer Discretionary Index. FDIS holds roughly 250 stocks but is top-heavy, with AMZN and TSLA historically accounting for around 40% of assets combined; RSPD holds about 48–50 large caps with each position near 2%.