FDIS is a broad, low-cost (0.08% expense ratio) index fund holding roughly 250 U.S. consumer discretionary stocks, while OND is a concentrated thematic fund of about 28 global "on-demand" companies with a materially higher 0.58% expense ratio. The two funds do not compete directly: FDIS targets the entire U.S. consumer discretionary sector, whereas OND targets a narrow, globally diversified subset spanning digital media, gaming, food delivery, and ridesharing.
Both funds target the U.S. consumer discretionary sector, but FDIS tracks a broad investable-market index with roughly 250 holdings, while XLY tracks a large-cap-only, S&P 500-based index with about 50 names. The two ETFs share near-identical top holdings—led by AMZN and TSLA —but FDIS is meaningfully more diversified, with lower single-name concentration risk.
Both FDIS and GXPD are passively managed U.S. consumer discretionary ETFs, but FDIS offers broad diversification across roughly 250 names, while GXPD uses a concentrated, uncapped “PureCap” approach with only about 46 holdings. FDIS tracks a 25/50-capped index, while GXPD is uncapped, allowing AMZN to command a weight above 40%—roughly double its weight in FDIS .
FDIS is a passively managed index ETF (exchange-traded fund) tracking the MSCI USA IMI Consumer Discretionary 25/50 Index, holding roughly 250 U.S. consumer-discretionary stocks. The fund is heavily concentrated at the top, with Amazon (about 22%) and Tesla (about 15%) together representing more than one-third of total assets.
Rate sensitivity is the defining risk: FDIS holds cyclical, interest-rate-sensitive companies, so the Federal Reserve's policy path on borrowing costs will heavily influence its near-term future outlook. Concentrated mega-cap exposure: Amazon and Tesla together represent a large share of the portfolio, making the fund sensitive to e-commerce and electric-vehicle demand trends.
VCR tracks a broad, market-capitalization-weighted consumer discretionary index, while XHB is an equal-weighted fund concentrated in the housing and building-products value chain. VCR holds roughly 280 stocks, whereas XHB holds about 35, making the two funds structurally very different despite some overlapping names.
OND is a concentrated, non-diversified thematic fund tracking the FactSet On-Demand Index, spanning global digital media, gaming, food delivery, ridesharing, and virtual reality companies. XHB is a passive, modified equal-weight fund tracking the S&P Homebuilders Select Industry Index, offering broad U.S. exposure across homebuilders, building products, and home-related retailers.
IYC is a broad, market-cap-weighted consumer discretionary fund holding roughly 170 stocks, with its top two names — AMZN and TSLA — accounting for around a fifth of total assets. XHB is an equal-weighted fund of roughly 35–40 names spanning homebuilders, building products, home improvement retail, and home furnishings, with no single position dominating.
PEJ ( PEJ ) is a multifactor, tiered equal-weight portfolio of roughly 30 U.S. leisure, travel, and entertainment stocks, while XHB ( XHB ) is a modified equal-weight basket of roughly 35 U.S. homebuilders and adjacent building-products companies. XHB is materially cheaper to own, with a 0.35% expense ratio versus PEJ's 0.58%, though PEJ's Intellidex methodology layers in fundamental and valuation screens that XHB's passive index does not.
Different exposure profiles: FDIS offers broad, market-cap-weighted coverage of the entire U.S. consumer discretionary sector, while XHB is a narrowly focused, equal-weighted basket centered on homebuilding and building products. Diversification gap: FDIS holds roughly 250 securities, whereas XHB holds only about 33–37 names, giving FDIS a structural edge in reducing single-stock risk.
ITB tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Select Home Construction Index, offering a concentrated basket of roughly 50 U.S. homebuilders, building-products manufacturers, and home-improvement retailers. Portfolio concentration is high, with the 10 largest holdings representing about two-thirds of assets, led by DHI , PHM , LEN , and NVR .
Both XHB and XRT are passively managed, modified equal-weight ETFs from the same issuer, State Street, with an identical expense ratio of 0.35%. XHB tracks the homebuilding and building-products ecosystem, while XRT covers the broad US retail industry across apparel, automotive, specialty, and food retail.
RSPD provides equal-weight exposure to roughly 48–49 consumer discretionary stocks drawn from the S&P 500, while XHB is a narrower, modified equal-weight basket of about 33–35 homebuilding and building-products companies. Both funds use an equal-weight methodology that reduces single-stock concentration, but RSPD spans the entire consumer discretionary sector, whereas XHB concentrates risk in a rate-sensitive housing theme.
ITB is a market-cap-weighted fund concentrated in large, pure-play homebuilders, while XHB uses a modified equal-weight approach spanning homebuilders, building products, HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air conditioning), and home-related retail. ITB's top holding can exceed 15% of assets, creating meaningful single-name concentration; XHB caps most positions near 3%–4%, delivering a flatter, more diversified profile.
FXD is a smart-beta fund tracking the StrataQuant Consumer Discretionary Index, selecting roughly 115 consumer discretionary names from the Russell 1000 using a multi-factor AlphaDEX methodology. XHB tracks the S&P Homebuilders Select Industry Index, an equal-weighted basket of about 35 companies spanning homebuilding, building products, and home improvement retail.
XHB tracks the S&P Homebuilders Select Industry Index, an equal-weighted basket of roughly 35 U.S. companies tied to housing, home products, and building materials. The fund is not a pure homebuilder play; it blends homebuilders with home improvement retail, home furnishings, and building products names, leaving consumer discretionary (about 60–67% of assets) and industrials (about 34%) as its dominant sector exposures.
ITB is a concentrated, market-capitalization-weighted theme fund focused on U.S. homebuilders and building products, while RSPD is an equal-weighted, broadly diversified consumer discretionary fund. Both are passively managed index exchange-traded funds (ETFs) with comparable fees — roughly 0.37% (net) for ITB and 0.40% for RSPD — but their risk profiles differ sharply.
Mortgage rates remain the dominant macro driver. The 30-year fixed-rate mortgage is expected to stay above 6% through 2026, keeping affordability constrained and pressuring near-term homebuyer demand. Housing supply is the structural wildcard. A persistent national shortfall supports long-term pricing, but pockets of oversupply in the Sun Belt and West Coast could weigh on builder margins and sales.
ITB is a passive, market-cap-weighted fund tracking the Dow Jones U.S. Select Home Construction Index, concentrating heavily in homebuilders and building-products companies. PEJ tracks a multifactor, tiered equal-weighted "Intellidex" index spanning airlines, hotels, restaurants, cruise lines, media, and travel-booking platforms.
Different strategies entirely: ITB targets U.S. residential home construction, while OND targets global "on-demand" digital platforms such as streaming, gaming, food delivery, and ridesharing. Cost gap is meaningful: ITB carries a roughly 0.37% expense ratio versus approximately 0.58% for OND, a structural cost advantage for ITB over time.