×
FSTA and VDC are near-identical, market-cap-weighted, ultra-low-cost staples trackers, while FXG is a pricier, rules-based smart-beta fund with a distinct mid-cap and food/agriculture tilt. Cost efficiency diverges sharply: FSTA charges 0.08%, VDC charges 0.09%, and FXG charges roughly 0.63% annually.
FXG is a smart-beta fund using First Trust's AlphaDEX multi-factor selection and tiered equal-weighting, tilting toward mid-caps and food producers. IYK is a market-cap-weighted benchmark tracker that blends roughly 13% healthcare exposure into an otherwise staples portfolio.
All three funds sit in the consumer staples universe, but they take sharply different routes: FXG is a U.S. smart-beta product, KXI is a global market-cap-weighted index fund, and PBJ is a concentrated food-and-beverage thematic portfolio. KXI offers the broadest diversification (roughly 100 holdings across global markets) and the lowest expense ratio at about 0.38–0.41%, versus 0.63% for both FXG and PBJ .
All three funds operate within the consumer staples universe, but they pursue very different strategies: FTXG is a concentrated food-and-beverage fund, FXG is a multi-factor "AlphaDEX" smart-beta fund, and RSPS is a broad equal-weight sector fund. On cost efficiency, RSPS is the clear leader with a 0.40% expense ratio, versus 0.60% for FTXG and 0.63% for FXG.
FXG and PSCC are both consumer staples ETFs (exchange-traded funds), but they target different segments: FXG leans toward large- and mid-cap staples, while PSCC focuses on small-cap names. FXG uses a smart-beta AlphaDEX methodology across roughly 41 holdings; PSCC is a passive, market-cap-weighted fund with about 27 holdings and is classified as non-diversified.
Both FXG and PBJ are smart-beta, rules-based ETFs focused on food, beverage, and consumer staples, but they pursue exposure through different indexes and screening methodologies. FXG holds roughly 41 stocks with broader sector reach, including healthcare distributors such as CAH and MCK , while PBJ is a more concentrated, non-diversified fund of about 30 to 32 food-and-beverage names.
FXG is a U.S.-only, rules-based (smart-beta) fund holding roughly 41 stocks, while KXI is a global, market-cap-weighted fund holding approximately 95 stocks. Cost and scale differ sharply: KXI charges a net expense ratio of about 0.39%, versus roughly 0.63% for FXG, and KXI manages substantially more in assets under management (AUM), supporting tighter trading liquidity.
FXG is a rule-based, fundamentally weighted fund built on the StrataQuant Consumer Staples AlphaDEX Index, tilting toward mid-cap food, beverage, and distribution names. VDC is a broad, market-cap-weighted fund tracking the MSCI US Investable Market Consumer Staples 25/50 Index, anchored by mega-cap household names.
FSTA is a low-cost, market-cap-weighted index fund tracking roughly 100 U.S. consumer staples stocks, while FXG is a rules-based "smart beta" fund using a modified equal-weight AlphaDEX methodology across about 41 holdings. FSTA carries a 0.08% expense ratio versus approximately 0.63% for FXG, giving FSTA a substantial cost-of-ownership advantage over long holding periods.
Different construction philosophies: FXG uses a multi-factor "AlphaDEX" smart-beta screen with modified equal weighting, while XLP is a straightforward market-cap-weighted replication of the consumer staples slice of the S&P 500. Cost gap is wide: XLP charges a 0.08% expense ratio versus roughly 0.63% for FXG, a structural cost advantage that compounds over time.
The First Trust Consumer Staples AlphaDEX Fund (FXG) is an ETF, not a single stock, so its "price target" is derived from public market discussion rather than a direct analyst consensus on the fund itself. A widely cited objective of roughly $71 (rounded from a TipRanks aggregate figure near $71.29) reflects the average analyst price target across the roughly 40-plus stocks the fund holds, with that aggregate ranging from about $62 to $83.
FXG tracks the StrataQuant Consumer Staples Index, a modified equal-dollar-weighted benchmark that screens U.S. consumer staples names from the Russell 1000 using the AlphaDEX methodology. The fund holds roughly 41 stocks, with the largest positions concentrated among packaged-food, meat and poultry, ingredient, and beverage companies.
FXG is a factor-based (smart beta) fund applying First Trust's AlphaDEX methodology — a modified equal-weight approach blending growth and value signals — to U.S. consumer staples stocks, producing a more mid-cap and diversified tilt across roughly 41 holdings. IYK is a traditional market-cap-weighted index fund tracking the Russell 1000 Consumer Staples RIC 22.5/45 Capped Index, concentrating heavily in mega-cap staples leaders across roughly 54 holdings.
Different weighting philosophies: FXG uses a multi-factor AlphaDEX selection model, while RSPS equal-weights S&P 500 consumer staples constituents. Cost gap: RSPS charges a 0.40% expense ratio, notably cheaper than FXG's 0.63%.
FTXG is a concentrated, mega-cap-tilted food and beverage pure-play with 31 holdings, while FXG offers a broader, more diversified 41-holding consumer staples basket with a meaningful mid-cap tilt. Both funds are passive and rules-based, but FTXG tracks a liquidity-selected, multi-factor-weighted index, whereas FXG uses the AlphaDEX equal-weighted "smart beta" selection methodology.
All three funds sit within the U.S. consumer staples universe, but their construction differs sharply: FTXG is a concentrated food-and-beverage smart-beta fund, RSPS equal-weights S&P 500 staples names, and VDC applies broad market-cap weighting. VDC is the most diversified and lowest-cost option, with more than 100 holdings and a 0.09% expense ratio, versus 0.40% for RSPS and 0.60% for FTXG.
Different scope: PBJ isolates U.S. food and beverage companies, while RSPS spans the entire consumer staples sector on an equal-weight basis. Cost advantage: RSPS carries a 0.40% expense ratio versus 0.61% for PBJ, a meaningful structural edge for long-term holders.
All three ETFs offer U.S. consumer staples exposure, but they differ sharply in construction: FSTA is a broad market-cap-weighted fund, RSPS is an equal-weight smart-beta strategy, and XLP is a concentrated large-cap sector fund. FSTA and XLP tie on cost at a 0.08% expense ratio, while RSPS is materially more expensive at 0.40%.
All three funds target the U.S. consumer staples sector, but they use fundamentally different construction methods: IYK is large-cap and market-cap weighted, PSCC is small-cap, and RSPS applies equal weighting to S&P 500 staples names. PSCC offers the lowest expense ratio at 0.29%, while IYK (0.38%) and RSPS (0.40%) carry moderately higher fees.
KXI is the most diversified and lowest-cost option, holding roughly 100 global consumer staples names for a 0.39% expense ratio, versus a narrower, higher-fee profile for FXG (0.63%). FXG uses a smart-beta "AlphaDEX" screening approach that tilts toward growth and value factors, giving it a mid-cap bias that is structurally different from the other two funds.